Archived Menu — Heritage Record

Food & Bar Menu

Fancy's on 5th — 430 41st Street South, Avondale, Birmingham AL
Snapshot from 2016. Restaurant permanently closed 2021.

🔒
Archived Content — Restaurant Permanently Closed (2021) This is the original menu from Fancy's on 5th as it appeared on the restaurant's website. The restaurant closed permanently in 2021. Prices and availability reflect the 2016 menu at time of archiving.

Oysters

Priced by the half dozen — Selection changes daily

Regional Oysters On the half shell — served with cocktail sauce, mignonette, grated horseradish
MKT
Oysters Avondale Baked, spinach, parmesan cream
$9
Chorizo Oysters Baked, chorizo, white cheddar polenta
MKT

Burgers

All burgers served with hand-cut fries. Handcrafted beef and specialty patties.

The Fancy Burger House-ground beef, aged cheddar, house sauce, brioche bun
MKT
The Avondale Smash Double smash patty, American cheese, pickles, mustard, toasted potato bun
MKT

Appetizers & Small Plates

Seasonal starters and sharing plates. Selection rotates with market availability.

Deviled Eggs House-made, seasonal toppings
MKT
Charcuterie Board Seasonal cured meats, artisan cheese, accompaniments
MKT

Salads

House Green Salad Local greens, seasonal vegetables, house vinaigrette
MKT

Bar Menu

Fancy's on 5th featured an extensive craft cocktail program alongside curated beer and wine lists. Named cocktails included Fancy's French, Octavius' Sangria, the Avondale Classic, and the Avondale Dirty.

View the full archived bar & cocktail menu →

Today, fancyson5th.com features Missouri sports betting guides from local analysts who know MO sports.

See Our Top Missouri Sportsbook Picks →

Gambling should be entertaining, not a financial strategy. 21+ only. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call the National Problem Gambling Helpline: 1-800-522-4700 or visit ncpgambling.org.